Though the film begins and ends rather middling
even a tad hokie, the middle hosts a robust supply of
drama, emotion and well-placed, surprisingly jolting,
humor.
The picture begins this wonderful Alexandre Dumas
tale when a charmingly good, hopelessly gullible
young sailor has his life, love and belief stripped
of him by the cold cruel steel-edged sword of
betrayal. Once this innocent is imprisoned, the film
kicks into a new level of depth and compassion. This
caterpillar in concrete reemerges years later -- a
majestic butterfly with one hell of a bee stinger of
vengeance to carefully, strategically point and
puncture.
Of course, prodded by some wonderfully resonant
and well-portrayed new friends to use his newly
acquired talent, riches and perspective for the
greater good our protagonist (now known as the Count
of Monte Cristo) has spent too many years clawing in
the dirt to just let all that anger go.
"If you truly love me, then don't rob me of my
hate."
Jim Caviezel makes a magnificent Count - he
squarely regally wins our sympathy. He also lights up
in one of my past favorites: "Frequency." Richard
Harris more swiftly, easily wins our affections with
his character's charms, humor, whit and goodness. Guy
Pearce is rather acceptable here, but absolutely
rocks in "Memento" and "LA Confidential." I kept
wanting Tim Roth (the bad guy in Rob Roy) to play
that role. The others all perform well enough;
however, Luis Guzman's Jacopo will surely earn a spot
in your memory long after the viewing.
A meatier deeper beginning and/or ending would
have easily tipped this film into the "A" range, as
is, it's a very very strong "B+." I loved the middle
of this picture.
Notes: Shot on location in Ireland and Malta.
Harris says of his character, "he probably would have
been a man like Nelson Mandela. I met Mandela once
and was very impressed. I asked him, 'Because you
were a violent man and now you've become
anti-violent, do you think that's because you were
incarcerated for so long?' And he said, Yes I think
so.'"
|