Former Secretary of Defense to JFK and LBJ, Robert
S. McNamara recounts the difficult decisions made in
the heat of the cold war, the Cuban Missile Crisis
and Vietnam. He retraces his steps in the blaring
light of hindsight in hopes of learning how best to
make decisions in the fog of future wars. Is it ever
morally right to take another persons life? When is
an action considered a war crime and when is it
national defense? At 85 years of age, NcNamara is
still incredibly sharp. Though at times refraining
from comment, for the most part, he's quite animated,
direct and surprisingly open about his conversations
and involvements during those trying times in our
world history that may have changed everything.
So interested was he in learning from his
mistakes, that McNamara flew over to Vietnam in 1995
to talk with the North Vietnamese General. The
General was furious about McNamara and the Americans
worrying about the Communist domino effect. He
pointed out that his country hated China, that his
men were only fighting for their independence, and
that they would have fought down to the last man.
Of McNamara's eleven spelled out lessons in this
documentary, the first strikes me as the most
fundamental: "Empathize with your enemy." Important
on the individual level, and even (dare I say) in
married couples, why would nations skip it?
Though the documentary itself is imperfect, full
of jump cuts and a Philip Glass theme that needles
one too many times, McNamara's storytelling and
insight engages completely. I could have
watched/listened for an hour more.
It's one of the most important films I've seen in
the last year or so. A matter of life and death,
required viewing for those sincerely interested in a
better understanding of war: from those that declare
it, to those that fight it, to those who (from the
safety of their homes) decide to support or
protest.
|