"Super cute south paw, has a chance if he can
harness that temper."
The film opens with Ryan (Prinze) sleeping on the
mound in preparation for the first big day of
practice. He's a local lawn boy with a wicked
pitching left arm. In "striking" contrast to Ryan's
supposedly equally wicked temper, Prinze maintains a
lower-key, relaxed acting persona. Ryan's wild past
is mentioned, though never defined; save for his
remarkable ability to self-destruct -- especially
after inning five.
Ward: "Maybe someone's trying to help you
out?"
Prinze: "I can screw this one up on my own."
The production would have bettered itself by
removing the whole "temper" idea from the picture (or
pitcher in this case); the "fear of failure" cloud
works well and serves more than enough to threaten
the parade.
Warm fuzzy moments "pop up" through out the film,
I got choked up once or twice. However, like Ryan
himself, "Summer Catch" throws inconsistently. Some
scenes fire right over the plate, others drift way
wide and outside. Additionally, sort of a jack of all
genres, master of none, "Catch" isn't really a
baseball picture, buddy film, coming of age, love
story, father-son-brother tale, "American Pie" type teen
comedy; though all genres are tagged rounding the
bases, none are able to bring the runners home.
Despite criticism from others, I actually like
Freddie Prinze Jr. and enjoyed the work he's done in
this picture. Unfortunately, while Jessica Biel is
"drop dead gorgeous" (that's a quote from Freddie),
she doesn't quite nail her role as the sassy rich
love interest. However, Brian Dennehy, Fred Ward and
Jason Gedrick each have their strong touching
moments.
And while I like the gist of this good-hearted
script, the final production could have been edited
with a heavier hand. A short sweet film bettering a
cluttered longer one.
|